With Koscielny Injured is it Holding or Chambers to Step Up? – Arsenal Supporters Poll

In truth, the sight of Skipper and on pitch leader, Laurent Koscielny being withdrawn injured has for years been a worrying one for Arsenal supporters. For some time, in the eyes of most of us the Frenchman was one of a decreasingly limited number of world class performers in the first team squad. We can all debate the semantics of what is truly world class but if Pep Guardiola wants to enlist your services, as he did with Koscielny, when at Bayern, I would suggest that is a fair indication.

However, as the player progresses into his thirties and the troublesome achilles proves more troublesome, Arsenal can no longer rely on their on-pitch captain being the player he once was or indeed, being available to play more than once a week. The lack of Champions League football has partially masked this issue, along with the unforgivable early departure from the FA Cup, because Wenger has been playing virtually an alternative team in the lesser European adventure. Now though, in the latter stages of the Europa League, with his route back into The ECL, unlikely via the Premier League, Wenger as he did last night will look to field his strongest team.

A concern but still a disaster?

I am not aware of the seriousness at this stage of Kos’s injury but the fact that he looked in some pain does set one to thinking about the alternatives. Although the enforced FA Cup break followed by the internationals may work in Arsenal’s favour on this occasion.  In recent weeks, with Per Mertesacker firmly in semi-retirement and Wenger having reverted to a back four, both Calum Chambers and Rob Holding have been given run outs alongside Mustafi. Both players have strong attributes and both have shown glimpse that they have the ability to play at the top level, but which, I wonder will be given the run, as partner to the German World Cup winner, if Koscielny is out for any period. Indeed, even if the Frenchman is able to return swiftly, with all eyes on the Europa it surely makes perfect sense to wrap him in cotton wool and give one of the Englishmen a run of games to forge a meaningful relationship with Mustafi.

To be entirely honest I like both Holding and Chambers and both have attributes to admire. The former so confident for a youngster in his first season culminating in the FA Cup win and the fans honouring him with Cannavaro comparisons and the latter back from a combative and rewarding loan spell at Boro. It is hard to tell which the current manager sees as ahead in the pecking order with both being afforded opportunities in 17/18 to press their claims.

Holding out for a starting berth

Holding, certainly in an aerial sense has the edge, which alongside Mustafi may be an advantage, with the German showing more heading prowess in the opposition box than his own. Both read the game quite well and sense danger but Chambers certainly has more ability to exit a tricky situation with footwork and has a marginally superior passing ability. Holding however, is swifter than his colleague across the pitch, which is a real asset in this league.

Two strong displays v Milan

So in short, not a simple decision but one that I suspect needs to be made straight away because whilst some Gooners are not convinced by Mustafi, he will play and be the senior partner to one of the English hopefuls.  Both candidates have a mistake in them and both would benefit from the top quality defensive coaching not afforded in the present regime. Both would also I imagine thrive more in a set up not utilising zonal marking. However, we are where we are for the time being so I thought, with this article in mind, I would go all ‘Who wants to be a Millionaire and ask the audience. Here is what close to 1000 Gooners voted over an 8-hour poll yesterday and I think that, on balance I agree.


Will Wenger agree on Calum Chambers over Rob Holding and do you? Let me know on Twitter and in comments.

Click to visit


, , ,

3 Responses to With Koscielny Injured is it Holding or Chambers to Step Up? – Arsenal Supporters Poll

  1. Alf Leaper March 17, 2018 at 10:25 am #

    Play both and omit Mustafi .

  2. Paul Habu March 17, 2018 at 5:56 pm #

    Both lads are talented, but i go for calum chamber

  3. sankalp nanda March 18, 2018 at 7:01 pm #

    Chambers. He had done enough to prove himself and needs repeated chances now.

Leave a Reply to Paul Habu Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes

%d bloggers like this: