Why does Wenger no longer see the need for a ‘On Pitch Leader’?


Coach and Captain 98

Coach and Captain 98

There is a nice story about Colin Bell – one of the very best Box-to-Box players in the late 1960s/early 1970s. He was physical stamina personified. Endless energy – a player who played extra time in every First Division match. He was trained by Malcolm Allison at Manchester City who watched every step of his prize player. He knew his body measurements and his capacity to run and run. He would work himself hard in training – would do the beach runs, the cliff runs, the sprints. No one trained harder than Colin Bell but he knew his limits. He knew when he was pushing himself to the limit – he knew when it was time to stop.

Colin Bell

Colin Bell

Or so he thought. Time and again as Bell was flagging Allison would appear and demand even more from his protégé. Shout, scream, curse, demand, insist and of course he got it. Bell always found something more and made the extra sprint, but not from within. His mind was exhausted; he could not summon the little bit extra from his own determination. It needed Allison the Bully

Allison cajouling the last ounze of energy

Allison cajouling the last ounze of energy

What is the point? Why Bell? Why Allison? It is the Captain thing. On the pitch with three minutes to go the players need to dig deep – in defence and in midfield and in attack. Each player has to double the effort to overcome mental and physical tiredness. And it is so easy to let it slip – not to make the run – not to track back – not to cover a colleague in defence – not to make the diversionary run wide of the area to pull a defender away like Perry Groves at Anfield in ’89.

It is on occasions like this that you need the dominating personality of the captain. The man who the players love and fear in equal measure. The person they look up to for leadership and example is a captain who they dare not let down – one glance from the boss on the pitch and you find the extra yard just as Colin Bell found that extra yard 45 years ago.

Coaches matter and Captains matter. Now this is my view. But I have never coached one player – never worked in football – never taken a coaching badge so professionals can shoot me down. They have been in the trenches and have experienced the tension and pressures and demands. But this is not just a football thing. It is a life thing.

Whether it is school or parents or bosses we all recognise the person whose presence makes you think twice – makes you roll up your sleeves and draw on reserves you never knew existed.

Click here to buy an incredible replica wall clock!

Get your replica wall clock here

When we talk of leaders at Arsenal we think of players from the past – Tom Parker who captained Chapman’s title winning team, Joe Mercer who was inspirational, Dave Bowen who revived the team after defeat at Northampton Town in the FA Cup in 1957/58. More recently we think of Adams and Vieira. There is an incident – can’t remember the opponents but Vivas was left back as I recall – we were leading 3-0 away and with a just a few minutes to go Vivas went missing. Maybe he switched off but Adams went for him – big time. We could all see it and it taught me something – never, never switch off – not just in football but in anything competitive.

What changed Arsene?

What changed Arsene?

Our players seem not to have that dominant personality. Is that because Wenger does not like players who are a little on the edge? Or is it because he thinks the captaincy thing is overdone? Is it because modern society tends to produce followers and not leaders? Whatever hi reason we do not have a fist waving, spirit pumping leader who squeezes the extra from his players.

Mata’s goal at Old Trafford seems to suggest that two players switched off – Monreal after Valencia went past him and Walcott who did not match Mata when he made the Scholes-like break for their goal. A rousing, demanding Captain will look for this. He will be watching the body language and wonder if his players are wilting. It may be a physical thing – it may be a mental thing. The player needs to be aware – the coach too and the captain as well and when a player drifts and lapses and there is a consequence he has to know he is going to get a  bollocking. We don’t want apologies – we want the errors not to occur. The players have to be so switched on – so determined. Concentration is everything.

We saw it in Copenhagen against Parma where we had to protect a slender one goal lead from Smudger. Adams was there directing operations – demanding more and then more and then more again. And the players responded and we won. But when on Saturday two players switched off at the same time something is wrong.

Two players allowed to switch off for Mata's goal

Two players allowed to switch off for Mata’s goal

I would love to know how Wenger sees it – how he addresses it. The problem is going to arise many times this season. The responsibility lies with the player. He has to have a high level of professional commitment. Never switch off. I always recall the moment in Patton when the British General chides Patton for promising more long marches and ever ready commitment to fight the enemy. “Your men must love you” says the General. Patton replies “No they fear me”. He then goes on to say that as soon as they cease to fear him that is when he loses his effectiveness. Every player should fear his Captain and his Coach for lack of effort – not lack of skill. Skill is not the issue but effort is everything. Are we 110%?

This is the image of a captain

This is the image of a captain

Thanks for reading. Until next time.

Graham Perry

, , ,

2 Responses to Why does Wenger no longer see the need for a ‘On Pitch Leader’?

  1. Peter November 23, 2016 at 1:38 pm #

    Excellent opinion. Add Ozil into the mix of players who go missing regularly. Would they do it if Roy Keane was on the pitch.? Then again would Arsene have Roy Keane on his team.?
    Our last 3 captains are players who are not regularly 1st name players on the teamsheet

  2. Victor Thompson November 24, 2016 at 11:25 am #

    This puzzles me Graham. Your loyalty to Arsene is legendary, yet this article seems to point towards the fact that the main factor of fear which you refer to is obviously what is missing from him. These players repeatedly fail to turn up and they don`t seem capable of raising their game when it happens. It happened against Man u and again last night against PSG.

    I`m afraid that whatever it takes to drag a performance out of players, Arsene does not have it. I have heard many ex players say that they loved Arsene, they were loyal to him because he is loyal to them. They respected him. They admired him etc. I have never heard of a player who said that he feared him. It was the main factor Fergie had which made him a great manager. People with big egos need to be handled by someone with an even bigger one. Ya Ya Toure learned his lesson this season and he had to apologise and grovel to Guardiola to get back onto the team.

    If winning trophies is any guide to being a successful manager, then I am afraid that we are not destined to see much evidence of that.

Your thoughts?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes

%d bloggers like this: